Man facing £100k bill and Contempt of Court Proceedings after Suspicious Compensation Claim

Sean Murphy had surgery for a torn bicep tendon in 2017, and during the operation his elbow was damaged. Sean claimed that this injury had left him unable to work, go to the gym or play rugby, and that he was dependent on his wife to help him get dressed. He sought compensation of £580,000 from the NHS. However, a tip-off was then received that Murphy had been dishonest when describing the extent of the impact on his day-to-day life. Solicitors pointed to evidence including videos on his Facebook account which appeared to show him lifting very heavy weights. They also noted that he had returned to work laying decking and tarmac, and that local media coverage of rugby matches included his name in the line up. Judge James Healy-Pratt dismissed Murphy's claim and he has been ordered to pay back £50,000 in compensation that he had already been paid. He also faces having to pay the legal costs of the NHS, with the total bill looking to be over £100,000. Murphy continues to argue that his claim was not dishonest. A further trial for contempt of court proceedings is due to take place. You can read more on the Metro website.

Other useful articles can be found in our Counter Fraud Newsletters on the Publications page